| 4th Quarter Play-by-Play |
| Olivet | 4-5 | on Hope12 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Olivet | 4-5 | on Hope12 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to Thomas Tobolic (Mark Karam). |
| | Drive: 10 plays, 62 yards, TOP 4:17 |
| Hope | 1-10 | on Hope12 | HOPE COLLEGE drive start at 14:55. |
| Hope | 1-10 | on Hope12 | Shawn Jackson rush for loss of 4 yards to the HOPE8 (Nick McCleary;Travis Farris). |
| Hope | 2-14 | on Hope08 | Shawn Jackson rush for 3 yards to the HOPE11 (Ryan Reurink;Ryan Armstrong). |
| Hope | 3-11 | on Hope11 | Michael Atwell sacked for loss of 6 yards to the HOPE5 (Ron Cadez). |
| Hope | 4-17 | on Hope05 | Aaron Thompson punt 27 yards to the HOPE32, downed. |
| | Drive: 3 plays, minus 7 yards, TOP 2:08 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | on Hope32 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 12:47. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | on Hope32 | Edric Miller rush for 2 yards to the HOPE30 (S. DiCesare;Kevin Kandow). |
| Olivet | 2-8 | on Hope30 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to James Williams. |
| Olivet | 3-8 | on Hope30 | Daniel Bolster pass complete to James Williams for 10 yards to the HOPE20, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Kevin Kandow). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | on Hope20 | Edric Miller rush for 20 yards to the HOPE0, 1ST DOWN OLIVET, TOUCHDOWN, clock 11:34. |
| | | Blake Iobe kick attempt good. |
| Hope College 21, Olivet College 7 |
| | Drive: 4 plays, 32 yards, TOP 1:13 |
| | | Blake Iobe kickoff 49 yards to the HOPE21, Chris Schmelz return 25 yards to the HOPE46 (Erik Critchlow). |
| Hope | 1-10 | on Hope46 | HOPE COLLEGE drive start at 11:27. |
| Hope | 1-10 | on Hope46 | Reggie Duncan rush for 5 yards to the OLIVET49 (A.J. Moore), PENALTY HOPE holding 10 yards to the HOPE36, NO PLAY. |
| Hope | 1-20 | on Hope36 | Michael Atwell pass incomplete to Luke Peterson. |
| Hope | 2-20 | on Hope36 | Michael Atwell sacked for loss of 5 yards to the HOPE31 (Cody Boughton). |
| Hope | 3-25 | on Hope31 | Reggie Duncan rush for loss of 11 yards to the HOPE20 (De'Marko Reed), PENALTY OLIVET personal foul (Cody Boughton) 15 yards to the HOPE35, 1ST DOWN HOPE. |
| Hope | 1-10 | on Hope35 | 1st and 10. |
| Hope | 1-10 | on Hope35 | Reggie Duncan rush for 3 yards to the HOPE38 (Jake Olson). |
| Hope | 2-7 | on Hope38 | Shawn Jackson rush for 57 yards to the OLIVET5, 1ST DOWN HOPE, out-of-bounds (Rob Jensen). |
| Hope | 1-G | on Olivet05 | Fluarry Jackson rush for 5 yards to the OLIVET0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 08:37. |
| | | Evan Finch kick attempt failed. |
| Hope College 27, Olivet College 7 |
| | Drive: 6 plays, 54 yards, TOP 2:50 |
| | | Benjamin Wells kickoff 54 yards to the OLIVET16, James Williams return 27 yards to the OLIVET43 (Mike Schatz). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | on Olivet43 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 08:28. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | on Olivet43 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete. |
| Olivet | 2-10 | on Olivet43 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to James Williams, dropped pass. |
| Olivet | 3-10 | on Olivet43 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to James Williams (Kyle Warren). |
| Olivet | 4-10 | on Olivet43 | Anthony Edwards punt 48 yards to the HOPE9, Chris Schmelz return 20 yards to the HOPE29, out-of-bounds (Jack Griggs). |
| | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 0:31 |
| Hope | 1-10 | on Hope29 | HOPE COLLEGE drive start at 07:57. |
| Hope | 1-10 | on Hope29 | Michael Atwell pass incomplete to Luke Peterson. |
| Hope | 2-10 | on Hope29 | Reggie Duncan rush for 8 yards to the HOPE37 (Jake Olson). |
| Hope | 3-2 | on Hope37 | Reggie Duncan rush for no gain to the HOPE37 (Ryan Reurink). |
| Hope | 4-2 | on Hope37 | Aaron Thompson punt 41 yards to the OLIVET22, fair catch by James Williams. |
| | Drive: 3 plays, 8 yards, TOP 1:29 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | on Olivet22 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 06:28. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | on Olivet22 | Edric Miller rush for 3 yards to the OLIVET25 (S. DiCesare). |
| Olivet | 2-7 | on Olivet25 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to Jon Beach, PENALTY OLIVET holding declined. |
| Olivet | 3-7 | on Olivet25 | Daniel Bolster pass complete to Edric Miller for 14 yards to the OLIVET39, 1ST DOWN OLIVET, out-of-bounds (S. DiCesare). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | on Olivet39 | Daniel Bolster pass complete to Edric Miller for loss of 3 yards to the OLIVET36 (Dan Karam;Mark Karam). |
| Olivet | 2-13 | on Olivet36 | Daniel Bolster sacked for loss of 7 yards to the OLIVET29 (Dan Karam). |
| Olivet | 3-20 | on Olivet29 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to Keegan Clark. |
| Olivet | 4-20 | on Olivet29 | Anthony Edwards punt 41 yards to the HOPE30, Chris Schmelz return 23 yards to the OLIVET47 (Erik Critchlow). |
| | Drive: 6 plays, 7 yards, TOP 2:59 |
| Hope | 1-10 | on Olivet47 | HOPE COLLEGE drive start at 03:29. |
| Hope | 1-10 | on Olivet47 | Russ Bernheisel at QB for Hope College. |
| Hope | 1-10 | on Olivet47 | Fluarry Jackson rush for 1 yard to the OLIVET46 (De'Marko Reed;Drew Miller). |
| Hope | 2-9 | on Olivet46 | Fluarry Jackson rush for 3 yards to the OLIVET43, out-of-bounds (Nick McCleary;Rob Jensen). |
| Hope | 3-6 | on Olivet43 | Russ Bernheisel pass intercepted by Aaron Breneman at the OLIVET41, Aaron Breneman return 0 yards to the OLIVET41. |
| | Drive: 3 plays, 4 yards, TOP 1:06 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | on Olivet41 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 02:23. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | on Olivet41 | Tony Phillips at QB for Olivet College. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | on Olivet41 | Eric Williams rush for 1 yard to the OLIVET42 (Nick Boeve). |
| Olivet | 2-9 | on Olivet42 | Eric Williams rush for loss of 2 yards to the OLIVET40 (Thomas Marine). |
| Olivet | 3-11 | on Olivet40 | Eric Williams rush for loss of 3 yards to the OLIVET37 (Mike Schatz). |
| Olivet | 4-14 | on Olivet37 | Timeout Hope College, clock 01:02. |
| Olivet | 4-14 | on Olivet37 | Tony Phillips sacked for loss of 5 yards to the OLIVET32 (Nick Boeve). |
| | Drive: 4 plays, minus 9 yards, TOP 1:43 |
| Hope | 1-10 | on Olivet32 | PENALTY HOPE unsportsmanlike conduct 15 yards to the OLIVET47. |
| Hope | 1-25 | on Olivet47 | HOPE COLLEGE drive start at 00:40, HOPE ball on OLIVET45. |
| Hope | 1-25 | on Olivet45 | 1st and 10. |
| Hope | 1-10 | on Olivet45 | Earl Schumake rush for no gain to the OLIVET45. |
| Hope | 2-10 | on Olivet45 | Nik D'Annunzio rush for no gain to the OLIVET45 (Cody Boughton). |
| Hope | 3-10 | on Olivet45 | Earl Schumake rush for 4 yards to the OLIVET41 (Justin Wilcox). |
| Hope | 4-6 | on Olivet41 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | Drive: 3 plays, 4 yards, TOP 0:40 |
